| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1901 64-62 | Nymeyer 17-15, 4.16 | Butler 10-22, 4.10 | Clampett 19-10, 2.67 | Thompson 16-15, 4.08 | Lange 0-0, 4.42 | Butler 1 SV, 4.10 | Butler 34 G, 4.10 | Clampett 33 G, 2.67 | Nymeyer 33 G, 4.16 | | 1902 66-60 | Thompson 19-18, 2.63 | Nymeyer 12-17, 4.00 | Clampett 12-11, 4.89 | Butler 20-14, 2.98 | Lange 1-0, 5.13 | Shaughnessy 2 SV, 4.79 | Thompson 39 G, 2.63 | Butler 38 G, 2.98 | Nymeyer 34 G, 4.00 | | 1903 67-59 | Butler 11-20, 2.82 | Jackson 20-11, 2.90 | Nymeyer 18-13, 2.85 | Thompson 15-14, 3.93 | Clampett 2-1, 1.69 | Thresher 6 SV, 0.79 | Butler 32 G, 2.82 | Jackson 32 G, 2.90 | Nymeyer 31 G, 2.85 | | 1904 72-68 | Jackson 17-17, 2.88 | Nymeyer 16-18, 3.90 | Thompson 20-14, 2.80 | Clampett 16-14, 3.97 | Lange 0-0, 4.84 | Thresher 1 SV, 4.43 | Jackson 36 G, 2.88 | Thompson 36 G, 2.80 | Nymeyer 35 G, 3.90 | | 1905 69-71 | Thompson 20-16, 3.09 | Nymeyer 18-17, 3.36 | Clampett 12-15, 3.62 | Pauls 12-20, 4.10 | Lange 1-0, 3.38 | Thresher 5 SV, 1.80 | Thompson 39 G, 3.09 | Nymeyer 36 G, 3.36 | Clampett 35 G, 3.62 | | 1906 73-67 | Thompson 17-16, 3.41 | Clark 20-15, 2.82 | Clampett 18-14, 3.06 | Pauls 9-16, 3.36 | Thresher 7-3, 1.57 | Thresher 7 SV, 1.57 | Thresher 45 G, 1.57 | Thompson 41 G, 3.41 | Clark 40 G, 2.82 | | 1907 59-81 | Lange 12-21, 3.70 | Clark 15-18, 3.29 | Pauls 10-15, 2.92 | Clampett 16-17, 3.24 | Thresher 5-10, 2.61 | Thresher 10 SV, 2.61 | Thresher 61 G, 2.61 | Clampett 48 G, 3.24 | Clark 46 G, 3.29 | |