| Year | Whitney Award | Allen Award | Kellogg Award | Reliever of the Year Award |
| 1911 CA | John Dibblee (CHC) | () | () | () |
| | .422/.501/.650, 6 HR, 15.7 WAR | | | |
| 1912 CA | Powell Slocum (BAL) | () | () | () |
| | .404/.466/.553, 2 HR, 9.0 WAR | | | |
| 1913 CA | Powell Slocum (2 ) (BAL) | () | () | () |
| | .435/.502/.577, 1 HR, 11.4 WAR | | | |
| 1914 CA | Powell Slocum (3 ) (BAL) | () | () | () |
| | .365/.449/.501, 2 HR, 9.1 WAR | | | |
| 1915 CA | Joe Ward (MON) | () | () | () |
| | .335/.401/.519, 0 HR, 12.1 WAR | | | |
| 1916 CA | Joe Ward (2 ) (MON) | () | () | () |
| | .328/.360/.513, 2 HR, 10.7 WAR | | | |
| 1917 CA | Powell Slocum (4 ) (BAL) | () | () | () |
| | .423/.489/.595, 2 HR, 10.1 WAR | | | |
| 1918 CA | Max Morris (CLE) | () | () | () |
| | .307/.428/.478, 5 HR, 4.6 WAR | | | |
| 1919 CA | Max Morris (2 ) (CLE) | () | () | () |
| | .342/.459/.542, 13 HR, 5.8 WAR | | | |
| 1920 CA | Danny Clark (CLE) | () | () | () |
| | .350/.399/.522, 1 HR, 7.9 WAR | | | |
| 1921 CA | Sam Sanderson (MON) | () | () | () |
| | .333/.413/.563, 26 HR, 6.9 WAR | | | |
| 1922 CA | Jack Gray (CHC) | () | () | () |
| | .365/.396/.531, 15 HR, 7.3 WAR | | | |
| 1923 CA | David Merchant (PHS) | () | () | () |
| | .337/.383/.515, 12 HR, 9.1 WAR | | | |
| 1924 CA | Rube Smith (PHS) | () | () | () |
| | 22-9, 2.21 ERA, 309.0 IP, 5.4 WAR | | | |
| 1925 CA | David Merchant (2 ) (PHS) | () | () | () |
| | .343/.399/.569, 15 HR, 7.6 WAR | | | |
| 1926 CA | Sandy Lovelle (BAL) | Dick Richards (NYS) | () | () |
| | .354/.434/.519, 6 HR, 6.1 WAR | 23-7, 2.42 ERA, 290.0 IP, 5.9 WAR | | |
| 1927 CA | Doug Lightbody (BRK) | Mose Smith (BRK) | () | () |
| | .384/.445/.586, 15 HR, 6.5 WAR | 19-14, 3.40 ERA, 302.0 IP, 7.4 WAR | | |
| 1928 CA | Tom Taylor (PHS) | Johnny Davis (PHS) | () | () |
| | .342/.422/.689, 44 HR, 10.0 WAR | 24-8, 2.73 ERA, 287.0 IP, 4.7 WAR | | |
| 1929 CA | Tom Taylor (2 ) (PHS) | Charlie Stedman (MON) | () | () |
| | .351/.441/.651, 38 HR, 9.8 WAR | 21-10, 2.99 ERA, 273.2 IP, 7.4 WAR | | |
| 1930 CA | John Lawson (NYS) | Rabbit Day (BAL) | () | () |
| | .392/.442/.613, 28 HR, 8.5 WAR | 22-10, 3.93 ERA, 316.0 IP, 6.8 WAR | | |
| 1931 CA | John Lawson (2 ) (NYS) | Milt Fritz (BRK) | () | () |
| | .359/.406/.502, 13 HR, 6.7 WAR | 23-15, 3.08 ERA, 318.1 IP, 6.1 WAR | | |
| 1932 CA | Lou Kelly (BAL) | Rabbit Day (2 ) (BAL) | () | () |
| | .355/.423/.637, 40 HR, 8.3 WAR | 19-15, 3.22 ERA, 324.1 IP, 8.4 WAR | | |
| 1933 CA | Max Morris (8 ) (CLE) | Tommy Wilcox (CHC) | () | () |
| | .325/.382/.580, 41 HR, 5.2 WAR | 21-11, 2.58 ERA, 286.1 IP, 6.8 WAR | | |
| 1934 CA | T.R. Goins (2 ) (CLE) | Tom Barrell (BRK) | () | () |
| | .349/.422/.512, 12 HR, 6.1 WAR | 29-3, 2.96 ERA, 319.1 IP, 8.4 WAR | | |
| 1935 CA | Al Wheeler (3 ) (BRK) | Tom Barrell (2 ) (BRK) | () | () |
| | .362/.437/.649, 34 HR, 6.7 WAR | 22-11, 2.86 ERA, 299.0 IP, 7.6 WAR | | |
| 1936 CA | Al Wheeler (4 ) (BRK) | Tom Barrell (3 ) (BRK) | () | () |
| | .359/.444/.604, 38 HR, 6.9 WAR | 21-6, 1 SV, 3.41 ERA, 306.0 IP, 8.1 WAR | | |
| 1937 CA | Al Wheeler (5 ) (BRK) | Joe Shaffner (BRK) | () | () |
| | .303/.401/.535, 30 HR, 5.3 WAR | 20-4, 2.32 ERA, 240.2 IP, 4.9 WAR | | |
| 1938 CA | Fred McCormick (TOR) | Dick Lyons (CHC) | () | () |
| | .367/.458/.565, 15 HR, 6.8 WAR | 20-6, 2.59 ERA, 250.0 IP, 5.4 WAR | | |
| 1939 CA | Fred McCormick (2 ) (TOR) | Joe Hancock (TOR) | () | () |
| | .399/.496/.673, 29 HR, 9.3 WAR | 15-13, 3.09 ERA, 277.0 IP, 7.2 WAR | | |
| 1940 CA | John Lawson (3 ) (CHC) | Walt Wells (PHS) | () | () |
| | .345/.399/.507, 17 HR, 6.8 WAR | 20-13, 3.10 ERA, 282.0 IP, 4.6 WAR | | |
| 1941 CA | Bill Barrett (NYS) | Pete Papenfus (CHC) | () | () |
| | .348/.471/.595, 33 HR, 10.2 WAR | 20-7, 2.84 ERA, 295.0 IP, 7.6 WAR | | |
| 1942 CA | Bill Barrett (2 ) (NYS) | Rufus Barrell II (CIN) | () | () |
| | .345/.492/.549, 27 HR, 12.3 WAR | 24-5, 1.76 ERA, 286.1 IP, 10.5 WAR | | |
| 1943 CA | Adam Mullins (CIN) | Rufus Barrell II (2 ) (CIN) | () | () |
| | .307/.418/.411, 4 HR, 6.1 WAR | 18-11, 2.08 ERA, 311.2 IP, 8.5 WAR | | |
| 1944 CA | Marion Boismenu (PHS) | Butch Smith (CIN) | () | () |
| | .354/.397/.449, 3 HR, 5.9 WAR | 19-10, 1 SV, 2.19 ERA, 283.2 IP, 6.0 WAR | | |
| 1945 CA | Walt Pack (TOR) | George Garrison (TOR) | () | () |
| | .301/.367/.514, 31 HR, 6.3 WAR | 19-8, 2.79 ERA, 267.2 IP, 9.3 WAR | | |
| 1946 CA | Bill Barrett (3 ) (NYS) | Pete Papenfus (2 ) (CHC) | Leo Hayden (BRK) | () |
| | .247/.402/.485, 30 HR, 5.7 WAR | 21-8, 2.39 ERA, 283.0 IP, 6.5 WAR | 19-12, 2.95 ERA, 278.0 IP, 4.5 WAR | |
| 1947 CA | Ralph Johnson (BRK) | Donnie Jones (CHC) | Ralph Johnson (BRK) | () |
| | .318/.414/.543, 25 HR, 7.4 WAR | 16-9, 2.89 ERA, 249.1 IP, 4.6 WAR | .318/.414/.543, 25 HR, 7.4 WAR | |
| 1948 CA | Bill Barrett (4 ) (NYS) | Rufus Barrell II (3 ) (CIN) | Pat Petty (BRK) | () |
| | .300/.421/.582, 43 HR, 8.2 WAR | 23-8, 2.15 ERA, 276.0 IP, 8.2 WAR | .284/.356/.457, 18 HR, 2.8 WAR | |
| 1949 CA | Ralph Johnson (2 ) (BRK) | Adrian Czerwinski (CLE) | Joe Austin (MON) | () |
| | .321/.427/.548, 27 HR, 8.7 WAR | 26-7, 2.88 ERA, 287.1 IP, 6.6 WAR | .310/.386/.455, 5 HR, 4.2 WAR | |
| 1950 CA | Ralph Johnson (3 ) (BRK) | Adrian Czerwinski (2 ) (CLE) | Larry McClure (CLE) | () |
| | .320/.410/.500, 19 HR, 7.0 WAR | 19-13, 3.31 ERA, 304.1 IP, 6.4 WAR | .337/.394/.550, 13 HR, 4.6 WAR | |
| 1951 CA | Sherry Doyal (CLE) | Adrian Czerwinski (3 ) (CLE) | Joe Wood (CLE) | () |
| | .326/.429/.549, 30 HR, 6.8 WAR | 22-7, 3.26 ERA, 292.2 IP, 7.2 WAR | .315/.406/.511, 14 HR, 4.6 WAR | |
| 1952 CA | Frenchy Sonntag (CLE) | () | Jerry Smith (CHC) | () |
| | .311/.380/.572, 35 HR, 7.8 WAR | | .265/.372/.482, 30 HR, 7.5 WAR | |
| 1953 CA | Ken Newman (KCK) | Fred Washington (KCK) | Charlie Barrell (NYS) | () |
| | .323/.454/.543, 24 HR, 8.5 WAR | 21-10, 2.50 ERA, 288.1 IP, 7.9 WAR | .310/.386/.528, 25 HR, 7.4 WAR | |
| 1954 CA | Ken Newman (2 ) (KCK) | Fred Washington (2 ) (KCK) | Dutch Miller (KCK) | () |
| | .310/.433/.517, 23 HR, 6.2 WAR | 28-8, 3.13 ERA, 319.1 IP, 8.0 WAR | .289/.381/.527, 26 HR, 5.8 WAR | |
| 1955 CA | Charlie Rogers (KCK) | Tony Britten (KCK) | Tom Reed (TOR) | () |
| | .331/.361/.525, 16 HR, 7.6 WAR | 20-11, 2.64 ERA, 276.1 IP, 8.0 WAR | .324/.383/.564, 25 HR, 5.2 WAR | |
| 1956 CA | Tom Carr (CLE) | Tony Britten (2 ) (KCK) | Johnny Elliot (LAS) | () |
| | .341/.430/.559, 9 HR, 9.2 WAR | 21-10, 2.09 ERA, 288.2 IP, 8.1 WAR | .356/.418/.528, 19 HR, 5.3 WAR | |
| 1957 CA | Dallas Berry (CIN) | Rufus Barrell II (4 ) (CLE) | Art McKinney (CIN) | () |
| | .315/.426/.658, 45 HR, 10.8 WAR | 22-11, 2.55 ERA, 292.2 IP, 9.5 WAR | .270/.325/.472, 22 HR, 3.2 WAR | |
| 1958 CA | Hank Williams (KCK) | Rufus Barrell II (5 ) (CLE) | Jerry McMillan (CHC) | () |
| | .387/.471/.647, 29 HR, 7.9 WAR | 19-11, 3.29 ERA, 287.1 IP, 8.7 WAR | .311/.357/.471, 18 HR, 4.8 WAR | |
| 1959 CA | Hank Williams (2 ) (KCK) | Adrian Czerwinski (4 ) (CLE) | Sid Cullen (TOR) | () |
| | .406/.490/.694, 34 HR, 10.6 WAR | 22-10, 2.82 ERA, 300.1 IP, 8.5 WAR | .285/.358/.505, 21 HR, 4.0 WAR | |
| 1960 CA | Dallas Berry (2 ) (CIN) | Arnie Smith (TOR) | Don Hall (LAS) | () |
| | .326/.461/.657, 42 HR, 10.4 WAR | 13-13, 3.44 ERA, 251.1 IP, 6.4 WAR | .284/.397/.481, 28 HR, 3.8 WAR | |
| 1961 CA | John Low (CLE) | Adrian Czerwinski (5 ) (CLE) | Pat Davis (KCK) | () |
| | .331/.419/.530, 14 HR, 7.4 WAR | 18-9, 3.54 ERA, 254.1 IP, 6.4 WAR | .343/.380/.543, 19 HR, 6.8 WAR | |
| | | | |
