| Date | Player | Strikeouts | |
| 05/18/1884 | Sidney Horace | 17 K, 5 BB and 9.0 IP versus New York while playing for Kansas City | |
| 06/12/1884 | Ray Hayden | 16 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus New York while playing for Brooklyn | |
| 07/28/1884 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 16 K, 3 BB and 9.1 IP versus New York while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 08/13/1884 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 18 K, 0 BB and 9.0 IP versus New York while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 08/14/1884 | Lew Anthony | 16 K, 0 BB and 9.0 IP versus New York while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 10/08/1884 | Ray Hayden | 15 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus New York while playing for Brooklyn | |
| 09/21/1887 | Ike Sawyer | 15 K, 3 BB and 9.0 IP versus Kansas City while playing for Montreal | |