 |
| |
| League History Index | Players | Teams | Managers | Leagues | Leaderboards | Awards | Accomplishments |
| Rank | Player | WAR | YEAR | Open Season Leaderboard |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Alfred Elder# | 39.19 | 1879-1889 | |
| 2 | Cyrus Pittman# | 29.71 | 1876-1890 | |
| 3 | Jasper Milson# | 21.29 | 1880-1889 | |
| 4 | Gene Deschamps# | 16.08 | 1884-1889 | |
| 5 | Charlie Rodgers | 15.63 | 1879-1884 | |
| 6 | Gene Parkhurst# | 11.56 | 1885-1889 | |
| 7 | Theo Black# | 9.93 | 1876-1889 | |
| 8 | Andy Stanhope# | 8.63 | 1879-1889 | |
| 9 | Oscar Grant# | 8.56 | 1889-1890 | |
| 10 | Tobias Brown | 7.00 | 1876-1885 | |
| 11 | Frank Moorman | 6.73 | 1879-1880 | |
| 12 | Cal Middleton# | 6.49 | 1880-1889 | |
| 13 | Lou Kirchner# | 6.29 | 1886-1889 | |
| 14 | Johnny Wallace | 6.06 | 1884-1887 | |
| 15 | Harvey Gibbons# | 5.89 | 1881-1885 | |
| 16 | Lou Curzon# | 5.83 | 1887-1890 | |
| 17 | Lew Schroeder# | 5.77 | 1881-1890 | |
| 18 | Albert Friermood | 4.52 | 1876-1878 | |
| 19 | Art Penick# | 4.42 | 1881-1890 | |
| 20 | Ben Schaefer# | 4.21 | 1888-1890 | |
| 21 | Joe Watlington# | 4.15 | 1888-1889 | |
| 22 | Gene Neumann# | 4.13 | 1887-1890 | |
| 23 | Art Gordon | 4.05 | 1879-1884 | |
| 24 | Tom Hollister# | 3.93 | 1888-1889 | |
| 25 | Edgar Woodard# | 3.79 | 1879-1889 | |
| 26 | Will Ross# | 3.75 | 1883-1890 | |
| 26 | Joe Underhill# | 3.75 | 1890-1890 | |
| 28 | Bob DeVilbiss | 3.73 | 1878-1878 | |
| 29 | Bill Wells | 3.59 | 1876-1885 | |
| 30 | Hiram Whitman# | 3.09 | 1879-1881 | |
| 31 | Irving Sullivan# | 2.97 | 1877-1885 | |
| 32 | George Smith | 2.69 | 1879-1882 | |
| 33 | Reginald Searle# | 2.48 | 1890-1890 | |
| 34 | James Wells | 2.44 | 1879-1879 | |
| 35 | Nate Locke# | 2.42 | 1880-1882 | |
| 36 | Martin Rogers# | 2.26 | 1884-1890 | |
| 37 | Samuel Schuyler | 2.16 | 1877-1879 | |
| 38 | Rufus Riddick# | 1.91 | 1878-1889 | |
| 39 | Walt Lopp# | 1.77 | 1880-1890 | |
| 40 | Lew Anthony | 1.52 | 1885-1889 | |
| 41 | Ezra Lockhart# | 1.50 | 1879-1889 | |
| 41 | Chester Greeley# | 1.50 | 1887-1890 | |
| 43 | Hermon Bowditch | 1.49 | 1876-1876 | |
| 44 | Henry Hazen | 1.04 | 1876-1878 | |
| 45 | Ray Kearney# | .94 | 1884-1889 | |
| 46 | Ed Larkins# | .93 | 1883-1885 | |
| 47 | Johnny Robertson | .91 | 1886-1886 | |
| 48 | Bill Scott | .82 | 1879-1880 | |
| 49 | Patty Connaughton | .67 | 1876-1880 | |
| 50 | Abraham Martin | .51 | 1884-1886 | |
| 51 | Fred Knott | .37 | 1879-1882 | |
| 52 | Jack Lewis | .31 | 1876-1878 | |
| 53 | Oscar Faust | .30 | 1878-1886 | |
| 53 | Frank Busby# | .30 | 1886-1889 | |
| 55 | Bob Carter | .26 | 1877-1878 | |
| 56 | Moses Benjamin | .25 | 1879-1887 | |
| 57 | Vic Montague# | .21 | 1879-1883 | |
| 58 | Kevin McCart | .19 | 1876-1881 | |
| 59 | Al Mallon# | .13 | 1886-1886 | |
| 60 | Ray Sears# | .09 | 1884-1885 | |
| 60 | Walter Carter | .09 | 1886-1886 | |
| 62 | Ed Treadwell# | .08 | 1884-1884 | |
| 63 | Bob Perry# | .06 | 1887-1889 | |
| 63 | Nate Jennings# | .06 | 1890-1890 | |
| 65 | Jack Fulp | .04 | 1886-1886 | |
| 65 | Hugh Granger# | .04 | 1890-1890 | |
| 67 | Matt Lynch# | .03 | 1888-1888 | |
| 67 | Dylan Connelly | .03 | 1876-1876 | |
| 69 | Douglas Glover | .02 | 1876-1878 | |
| 70 | Augie McDonald | .01 | 1883-1883 | |
| 71 | George Bauer# | .00 | 1881-1885 | |
| 72 | Dan Hawley# | -0.01 | 1882-1882 | |
| 73 | Al Gorman# | -0.04 | 1890-1890 | |
| 74 | Edward Wakeham | -0.05 | 1876-1877 | |
| 75 | Michael Thomas | -0.06 | 1885-1885 | |
| 76 | Will Tolbert# | -0.08 | 1887-1889 | |
| 76 | Chester Bartlett# | -0.08 | 1886-1886 | |
| 78 | Ray Dread# | -0.09 | 1885-1885 | |
| 78 | George Caron# | -0.09 | 1885-1885 | |
| 80 | Harry Riggs# | -0.11 | 1890-1890 | |
| 81 | Jerry Mullen# | -0.15 | 1890-1890 | |
| 82 | Ben Edwards | -0.17 | 1885-1889 | |
| 83 | Pat Norcross# | -0.27 | 1886-1886 | |
| 83 | Anderson Belk | -0.27 | 1883-1883 | |
| 85 | Fred Miller# | -0.28 | 1890-1890 | |
| 86 | Jack Pinkerton | -0.49 | 1876-1883 | |
| 86 | Lloyd Brumback | -0.49 | 1876-1879 | |
| 88 | Jasper Smith | -0.89 | 1883-1886 | |
| 89 | Joe Robie# | -0.95 | 1886-1886 | |
| 90 | Edgar Weston | -1.12 | 1876-1879 | |
| 91 | George Ellis | -1.18 | 1882-1882 | |
| 92 | Otis Sheehan# | -1.74 | 1882-1883 | |
| 93 | Charlie DeVault | -2.71 | 1884-1889 | |
| 94 | Hugo Lamb | -3.08 | 1876-1884 |
