 |
| |
| League History Index | Players | Teams | Managers | Leagues | Leaderboards | Awards | Accomplishments |
| Rank | Player | WAR | YEAR | Open Season Leaderboard |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | George Pruitt | 76.25 | 1894-1912 | |
| 2 | Jimmy Whipple | 63.77 | 1904-1921 | |
| 3 | Walt Messer* | 63.28 | 1939-1956 | |
| 4 | Jake Hooper | 62.56 | 1908-1926 | |
| 5 | Jim Hampton | 62.06 | 1926-1941 | |
| 6 | George Dunlap | 61.27 | 1890-1905 | |
| 7 | Fred Huffman | 55.65 | 1908-1926 | |
| 8 | Leo Mitchell | 55.22 | 1935-1955 | |
| 9 | Jesse Alvardo | 53.10 | 1943-1959 | |
| 10 | Thomas Watkins* | 49.03 | 1888-1904 | |
| 11 | Bob Sykes | 43.27 | 1894-1907 | |
| 12 | Bill Craigen* | 41.94 | 1899-1917 | |
| 13 | Lem Rodgers | 41.40 | 1906-1920 | |
| 14 | Tom Reed | 41.39 | 1952-1969 | |
| 15 | Henry Jones | 41.02 | 1928-1945 | |
| 16 | Bill Newhall | 40.54 | 1950-1967 | |
| 17 | Larry Gregory | 40.51 | 1944-1962 | |
| 18 | Paul Bailey | 39.13 | 1920-1932 | |
| 19 | Otis O'Keefe | 38.70 | 1949-1964 | |
| 20 | Tony Seide | 38.64 | 1912-1924 | |
| 21 | Billy Woodruff | 38.23 | 1899-1912 | |
| 22 | Rip Curry | 38.10 | 1934-1952 | |
| 23 | Jim Watson | 37.36 | 1932-1945 | |
| 24 | Bill Morris | 36.51 | 1912-1922 | |
| 25 | Danny Davis# | 36.14 | 1962-1974 | |
| 26 | Dallas Berry | 36.10 | 1953-1971 | |
| 27 | Phil Sandman | 35.90 | 1923-1936 | |
| 28 | Moxie Pidgeon | 35.81 | 1928-1945 | |
| 29 | Billy Joe Davis | 35.62 | 1906-1923 | |
| 30 | Frank Kirouac# | 34.81 | 1962-1974 | |
| 31 | Dave Grigsby | 34.77 | 1878-1895 | |
| 32 | Bert Lass | 33.36 | 1938-1949 | |
| 33 | Mike Whisman | 33.26 | 1959-1972 | |
| 34 | Buddy Miller# | 33.16 | 1951-1974 | |
| 35 | Ben Jameson | 32.31 | 1892-1903 | |
| 36 | Joe Owens | 32.07 | 1933-1955 | |
| 37 | Bobby Barrell* | 31.55 | 1931-1952 | |
| 38 | Joe Perret | 30.47 | 1927-1942 | |
| 39 | Art Charles | 30.37 | 1923-1929 | |
| 40 | Gustav Gray | 30.30 | 1882-1893 | |
| 41 | Silas Leis | 29.93 | 1907-1919 | |
| 42 | Eddie Gaiser | 29.47 | 1917-1927 | |
| 43 | Cy Lynch | 29.37 | 1916-1931 | |
| 44 | Jeff Greene | 29.24 | 1886-1901 | |
| 45 | Harry Rowell | 28.63 | 1907-1918 | |
| 46 | Jack Easton | 27.24 | 1883-1892 | |
| 47 | Bill Barrett* | 26.59 | 1938-1960 | |
| 48 | Pat Davis# | 26.37 | 1961-1974 | |
| 49 | Sam Morrison# | 26.34 | 1966-1974 | |
| 50 | Joe Watson | 26.09 | 1933-1949 | |
| 51 | Martin Thomas | 26.01 | 1886-1904 | |
| 52 | Bill Faulkner | 26.00 | 1901-1915 | |
| 53 | Art Panko | 25.67 | 1922-1932 | |
| 54 | Bill Williams | 25.62 | 1880-1906 | |
| 55 | Harry Dunn | 25.13 | 1908-1922 | |
| 56 | Jim Smith# | 24.72 | 1966-1974 | |
| 57 | Johnny Adams# | 23.82 | 1965-1974 | |
| 58 | Joe Shoemaker | 23.60 | 1920-1927 | |
| 59 | Alex Ingraham | 23.52 | 1930-1938 | |
| 60 | Dick Estes | 23.39 | 1946-1962 | |
| 61 | Ricardo Castillo# | 23.31 | 1964-1974 | |
| 62 | Tom Carr | 23.21 | 1953-1971 | |
| 63 | Dode Caudill# | 23.16 | 1963-1974 | |
| 64 | Ira Phillips | 22.83 | 1890-1901 | |
| 65 | Jack Welch | 22.82 | 1946-1957 | |
| 66 | Jim Bailey | 22.76 | 1909-1920 | |
| 67 | Ira Williams | 22.75 | 1887-1903 | |
| 68 | Tom Larrinaga | 22.56 | 1919-1926 | |
| 69 | Ed Dodge# | 22.33 | 1964-1974 | |
| 70 | Francis Houston | 22.05 | 1894-1908 | |
| 71 | Ralph Chase | 21.97 | 1915-1924 | |
| 72 | Dom Pappas | 21.91 | 1914-1924 | |
| 73 | Warren Huff | 21.74 | 1888-1894 | |
| 74 | Jerry Smith* | 21.73 | 1951-1969 | |
| 75 | John Kingsbury# | 21.50 | 1960-1974 | |
| 76 | Otis Ballard | 21.42 | 1951-1962 | |
| 77 | Doc Love | 21.25 | 1931-1949 | |
| 78 | Bill Calvin# | 21.16 | 1965-1974 | |
| 79 | Tim Johnson | 20.99 | 1920-1929 | |
| 80 | Harry Myers# | 20.74 | 1965-1974 | |
| 80 | Joe Phelan | 20.74 | 1890-1904 | |
| 82 | Art Summers | 20.59 | 1929-1935 | |
| 83 | Jay Fry | 20.28 | 1915-1923 | |
| 84 | Doc Zimmerman | 20.27 | 1955-1970 | |
| 85 | Red Henry | 20.22 | 1916-1923 | |
| 86 | Pat Petty | 20.20 | 1947-1962 | |
| 87 | Joe Borden | 20.19 | 1888-1893 | |
| 88 | Elisha Wallace | 20.11 | 1879-1891 | |
| 89 | Alfie Barr | 20.09 | 1917-1927 | |
| 90 | John Dibblee* | 19.98 | 1906-1931 | |
| 91 | Alf Deschamps | 19.58 | 1887-1895 | |
| 92 | Orlando Benitez# | 19.57 | 1964-1974 | |
| 93 | Al Wheeler* | 19.55 | 1928-1947 | |
| 94 | Elmer Ratchford | 19.34 | 1890-1898 | |
| 95 | John Hamilton | 19.20 | 1906-1916 | |
| 96 | Pete Lee# | 19.16 | 1964-1974 | |
| 97 | Don Riley# | 19.01 | 1965-1974 | |
| 98 | Davey Robicheaux | 18.96 | 1940-1954 | |
| 99 | Joe Cantrell# | 18.84 | 1966-1974 | |
| 100 | Carlos Cano | 18.75 | 1925-1933 |
