 |
| |
| League History Index | Players | Teams | Managers | Leagues | Leaderboards | Awards | Accomplishments |
| Rank | Player | WAR | YEAR | Open Season Leaderboard |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cal Middleton# | 55.91 | 1880-1899 | |
| 2 | Elmer Aubert# | 54.90 | 1885-1899 | |
| 3 | Cornelius Quimby | 42.65 | 1878-1897 | |
| 4 | Otis Wentworth# | 39.11 | 1878-1899 | |
| 5 | Art Brogan# | 37.13 | 1892-1899 | |
| 6 | Nate Galvin# | 30.80 | 1887-1899 | |
| 7 | Jean Beckwith# | 27.02 | 1890-1899 | |
| 8 | Elmer McKinzy# | 26.59 | 1885-1899 | |
| 9 | Oliver Menzies# | 17.64 | 1891-1899 | |
| 10 | Ed Monahan# | 15.32 | 1887-1899 | |
| 11 | Glenn Fittan | 14.73 | 1878-1889 | |
| 12 | Claude Heaton# | 14.13 | 1889-1899 | |
| 13 | Otto Keating# | 12.82 | 1888-1899 | |
| 14 | Chester Noonan# | 10.73 | 1884-1899 | |
| 15 | Moses Benjamin | 9.39 | 1879-1887 | |
| 16 | Joe Whitcomb# | 8.09 | 1876-1883 | |
| 17 | David Meehan# | 7.97 | 1889-1899 | |
| 18 | Vic Nesbitt# | 7.71 | 1890-1899 | |
| 19 | Chester Ashby# | 7.43 | 1892-1899 | |
| 20 | Lou Curzon# | 6.16 | 1887-1899 | |
| 21 | Milton Beach# | 5.82 | 1879-1883 | |
| 22 | Hugo Lamb | 5.69 | 1876-1884 | |
| 23 | Steve Airington | 5.61 | 1876-1889 | |
| 24 | Art Phelps | 5.59 | 1882-1882 | |
| 25 | Milton Gatlin | 4.69 | 1888-1890 | |
| 26 | Theo Black | 4.33 | 1876-1894 | |
| 27 | Cliff Holland | 4.28 | 1876-1881 | |
| 27 | Len Parramore# | 4.28 | 1891-1899 | |
| 29 | Dan Colby | 3.80 | 1882-1882 | |
| 30 | Jimmy Graham | 3.56 | 1879-1885 | |
| 31 | Oscar Featherstone | 3.41 | 1887-1895 | |
| 32 | Hugh Weaver# | 3.04 | 1890-1891 | |
| 33 | Cal Jones | 3.02 | 1876-1881 | |
| 34 | Jack Cassell | 2.79 | 1881-1888 | |
| 35 | George Smith | 2.75 | 1879-1882 | |
| 36 | Samuel Schuyler | 2.43 | 1877-1877 | |
| 37 | Dow Walker | 1.80 | 1876-1879 | |
| 38 | Lew Cormack# | 1.77 | 1892-1893 | |
| 39 | John Patrick | 1.68 | 1880-1883 | |
| 40 | Andy Stanhope | 1.49 | 1879-1889 | |
| 41 | Roy Randle# | 1.36 | 1896-1899 | |
| 42 | Judson Perry | 1.32 | 1885-1887 | |
| 43 | Denny Reardon# | 1.13 | 1887-1899 | |
| 44 | James Pepp | 1.08 | 1879-1880 | |
| 45 | George Avery# | .92 | 1886-1890 | |
| 45 | Ed Peacher | .92 | 1876-1877 | |
| 47 | Ike Walling | .79 | 1880-1885 | |
| 48 | Harry Coady# | .71 | 1885-1889 | |
| 49 | Hal Ryder# | .63 | 1890-1891 | |
| 50 | Harry Hamm | .44 | 1885-1885 | |
| 51 | Tommy Allen | .43 | 1886-1886 | |
| 52 | Bill Miller | .40 | 1878-1880 | |
| 53 | Charley Guidry | .38 | 1884-1885 | |
| 54 | Pat Ellis | .36 | 1884-1885 | |
| 55 | Ben Milon | .35 | 1876-1876 | |
| 56 | Will Leverett# | .34 | 1890-1890 | |
| 57 | Ben Gladstone | .33 | 1877-1885 | |
| 58 | Will Gardner | .32 | 1891-1896 | |
| 59 | Martin Criswell | .22 | 1889-1890 | |
| 60 | Fred Dickinson# | .21 | 1890-1899 | |
| 61 | Ed Ragsdale# | .20 | 1890-1891 | |
| 62 | Ambrose Mullins | .16 | 1884-1888 | |
| 63 | Ossie Cowan | .14 | 1883-1883 | |
| 64 | Cyrus McKelvie | .11 | 1876-1884 | |
| 65 | Al Roberts | .08 | 1883-1888 | |
| 66 | Clyde Evans# | .07 | 1888-1889 | |
| 66 | Herbert Younge | .07 | 1890-1890 | |
| 68 | Art Francois# | .06 | 1898-1899 | |
| 68 | Chester Lynde# | .06 | 1889-1889 | |
| 68 | Johnny Kildare | .06 | 1876-1882 | |
| 71 | Preston Wilson | .05 | 1886-1886 | |
| 71 | Oscar Eaton | .05 | 1893-1893 | |
| 73 | Al Myers | .04 | 1882-1885 | |
| 73 | Otis Foley | .04 | 1884-1884 | |
| 73 | Cal Churchill | .04 | 1889-1889 | |
| 73 | Ed Carpenter | .04 | 1890-1890 | |
| 73 | Ephraim Gallagher | .04 | 1881-1889 | |
| 73 | Joe Griffin | .04 | 1884-1884 | |
| 79 | George Duncan# | .03 | 1885-1885 | |
| 80 | Frank Morton# | .01 | 1890-1890 | |
| 81 | Hank Vail | -0.01 | 1890-1890 | |
| 81 | Albert Brannock | -0.01 | 1876-1879 | |
| 81 | Lou Epps# | -0.01 | 1890-1890 | |
| 81 | Elmer Godette | -0.01 | 1884-1885 | |
| 81 | Elmer Fitzpatrick# | -0.01 | 1887-1890 | |
| 86 | Joe Morris | -0.02 | 1880-1880 | |
| 86 | Thomas Bryant | -0.02 | 1882-1884 | |
| 88 | Fred Douglas | -0.03 | 1886-1887 | |
| 89 | Charley Devereux | -0.04 | 1892-1892 | |
| 89 | Joe Flynn | -0.04 | 1876-1879 | |
| 91 | John Morine | -0.05 | 1883-1884 | |
| 91 | Marcus Swain | -0.05 | 1878-1878 | |
| 91 | Bob Blanks | -0.05 | 1889-1889 | |
| 94 | Ray Donaldson# | -0.06 | 1890-1890 | |
| 94 | George Roth | -0.06 | 1885-1885 | |
| 94 | Bernard Heineman | -0.06 | 1889-1890 | |
| 97 | Billy Wells | -0.08 | 1887-1887 | |
| 98 | Elmer Horton# | -0.09 | 1895-1899 | |
| 99 | Danny O'Riordan | -0.10 | 1881-1885 | |
| 100 | Harvey Keller | -0.12 | 1890-1891 |
